This entry was corrected on 20 September 2026. Two things it said were wrong: the period, which runs from 1 May 2014 to 30 June 2024, and the claim that the study applied one set of criteria to both sides. The source records Palestinian and Israeli casualties under different verification rules, and says so. The journal of corrections carries both previous versions.
| Document | Occupation, displacement, and violence in the West Bank: A retrospective analysis of data from 2014–2024 1 |
| Published | 2025-06-25 |
| Address | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004829 |
| Access | primary |
| Period covered | 2014-05-01 → 2024-06-30 |
| Corroboration | single-source |
The document was re-opened on 2026-09-28 and the quoted sentence appears in it word for word, at the address below.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004829
How this is checked, and how to check it yourself
How the source established it
Cross-sectional analysis of the UN humanitarian office’s Protection of Civilians database for the West Bank and Israel, 1 May 2014 to 30 June 2024. Before the study’s exclusions the database held 112,837 Palestinian (96.4%) and 4,177 Israeli (3.6%) casualties; Gaza casualties (n = 43,584) were then excluded. The two sides do not enter the database under the same verification rule — see the reserves.
What the source does not claim
The database does not record the two sides the same way. The authors state it in their limitations: “Palestinian casualties are only recorded if there is two-source verification, whereas this is not the case for Israeli casualties.” They add that this “may lead to underestimation of Palestinian injury rates” and that, since two-source verification is only used for Palestinian casualties, “there is a risk of misclassification bias for Israeli casualties, including those that may be Palestinian citizens of Israel”. In the methods the exception is put on Israeli injuries: for an incident to be entered onto the database, information … must be validated “by at least two independent and reliable sources”, and “Incidents resulting in Israeli injuries are an exception to this rule, where information is based on media reports”.
Methods, “Data sources and extraction”; Limitations
Casualties “in the context of the ongoing hostilities in Gaza and Israel, which started on 7 October 2023” had “yet to be added to the database as they are awaiting independent verification” at the time of analysis; the same paragraph adds that “data on casualties in the West Bank and Israel in other contexts is updated beyond 7 October 2023”. The authors write that the absence of casualties related to the hostilities as of 7 October 2023 “may lead to underestimation of both Palestinian and Israeli death and injury rates”.
Methods, “Data sources and extraction”; Results, “Typology of attacks”; Limitations
The period is 1 May 2014 to 30 June 2024. Casualties that occurred in Gaza (n = 43,584) were excluded from the analysis. The rate comparisons of table 1 stop earlier still, at 30 December 2023, for want of 2024 population data.
Methods, “Study design”; Results; table 1
“Casualties” combines deaths and injuries. The study reports the two separately: 1,092 deaths and 68,220 injuries.
Results, “Conflict-related traumatic injuries and deaths”
The authors write that those injured “are recorded only if they were physically hurt in a relevant incident and received medical treatment at a clinic or hospital, or by paramedic personnel”, and that “minor injuries are not recorded within the database leading to underreporting”. Severity is not given in the database, and the authors write: “It is also unclear if delayed deaths due to conflict-related injury are updated within the database.”
Methods, “Data sources and extraction”; Limitations
Who counted
Both counts come from one database, the UN humanitarian office’s Protection of Civilians database, into which, the article says, its field staff regularly enter the data; for incidents resulting in Israeli injuries, the information “is based on media reports”. The database does not apply the same verification rule to the two sides.
Note from the register
The companion figure for Israeli casualties is entry westbank-2025-002. Neither is published without the other.
— Only Receipts
Provenance and verification — where this document came from, and what we could not
check ourselves
- The article was read in full on 20 September 2026 from the publisher’s own site, which asks thirty seconds between requests; the delay was kept. It was first read on 19 September 2026 through the public medical index. The sentences quoted here were checked word for word against the publisher’s text.
- The asymmetry in the source’s own recording is carried on both entries of this pair, in the same words. Neither side’s figure is given without it.
Words used here, and what each one means:
Casualties · Deposit and validation
Cite this — the source document first, this entry second
Citing the document is what carries weight. This entry is where
you found it.
Plain text
PLOS Global Public Health. Occupation, displacement, and violence in the West Bank: A retrospective analysis of data from 2014–2024. 2025-06-25. At Results, “Conflict-related traumatic injuries and deaths”. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004829.
Consulted via Only Receipts, entry westbank-2025-001, https://www.onlyreceipts.org/entries/westbank-2025-001/ (entry last changed 2026-10-03).
BibTeX
@misc{onlyreceipts-westbank-2025-001,
author = {PLOS Global Public Health},
title = {Occupation, displacement, and violence in the West Bank: A retrospective analysis of data from 2014–2024},
year = {2025},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004829},
urldate = {2026-09-18},
note = {Results, “Conflict-related traumatic injuries and deaths”. Consulted via Only Receipts, https://www.onlyreceipts.org/entries/westbank-2025-001/},
} RIS — Zotero, EndNote, Mendeley
TY - RPRT
AU - PLOS Global Public Health
TI - Occupation, displacement, and violence in the West Bank: A retrospective analysis of data from 2014–2024
PY - 2025
DA - 2025/06/25
UR - https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0004829
N1 - Locator: Results, “Conflict-related traumatic injuries and deaths”
N1 - Consulted via Only Receipts, entry westbank-2025-001, https://www.onlyreceipts.org/entries/westbank-2025-001/
ER -